Minnesota

REVIEW

Brandi Carlile Returns to Us at the State Theatre

No phones, no setlist, no arena. Just Brandi, the twins, and a theater full of people who have loved her for 20 years.
Brandi Carlile sings between Phil and Tim Hanseroth, who hold acoustic guitars, around a single microphone in a theater balcony.
Brandi Carlile with Phil and Tim Hanseroth at the State Theatre on Nov. 18.

This Brandi Carlile review is brought to you by the State Theatre front-of-house team, and by the pink pen and scratch paper they handed an ADHD lesbian who didn’t get the no-phones memo.

Wednesday was night two of Burn the Setlist in Minneapolis, and it was phone-free, like the whole tour has been. People with executive functioning who use their phone as their notebook made other arrangements. Alas, this reviewer did not.

Nell Gelhaus stands in the aisle of the State Theatre holding up a pink pen, a sheet of handwritten notes in her other hand.
The reviewer, the pink pen and the scratch paper.

When Carlile announced the tour on Instagram, she said it would be her and the twins (her longtime bandmates, brothers Phil and Tim Hanseroth) doing 15 shows in theaters that meant a lot to them early in their careers.

The Gaily Show. Radio and online. Queer news. Progressive. Daily.
Q Thursdays Jingle & Mingle: Thursday, December 3, 5:30 to 8 PM, LUSH Lounge & Theater, Minneapolis. Free to attend.

It made for one of the most poignant nights I’ve had at a Brandi show, and I’ve done my fair share of following her around North America. Confession, though: I’m not OG Bramily. My ex-wife introduced me to Brandi early in our relationship. She’d been following her for years, like probably most of that audience.

Wednesday night’s crowd was not the didn’t-she-sing-that-one-song crowd. It wasn’t the Girls Just Wanna Weekend crowd, either. (The backpack tags from those are the silently agreed-upon national lesbian identifiers, btw. Fair warning, all y’all straight folks just trying to keep track of your luggage.)

But it was a crowd where somebody near you has seen her more times than you have. We met David, a superfan from Colorado, there with his dad. He’s been to more than 150 Brandi shows, and sang along to every word of this one.

Something happens when a couple thousand people have to put their phones away. We looked up. We looked around. There was accidental, almost shy eye contact, and small smiles between strangers who all knew we were in the same moment and that it was a good one. Thank you for that gift, Brandi. I keep wondering what would happen if we all looked up a little more.

About that setlist. Maybe you thought “Burn the Setlist” was just a cute marketing phrase. Um, no. They really didn’t have a plan walking out onto that stage, other than to turn up the house lights and pick some songs to play.

So everybody with executive functioning who prepared ahead of time brought a sign with their song pick on it. Brandi and the twins read the signs, picked a few, wrote them in Sharpie on a big pad on an easel, played them, and then read some more signs. They kept that up for about three and a half hours. We were enthralled.

A Bar of Their Own. Women's sports, queer joy, and a seat at the bar for everyone. abaroftheirown.com, 2207 E. Franklin Ave, Minneapolis.

You probably knew this already, but we’re really good at signs in Minnesota. We’ve been marching around with them a lot lately. The bedazzling and the artistry didn’t surprise me, but holy cow, there were hundreds, front of the floor to the back of the balcony.

Fans along the State Theatre balcony rail hold up dozens of handmade song request signs.
Song requests along the balcony rail.
  • “This Time Tomorrow” in a frame of fall leaves and string lights.
  • A set of gold 1984 balloons for “Christmas 1984.”
  • Three “Pride & Joy” signs in a single row, in case she missed the first two. (We didn’t get that one on night two, which stings, because it’s my go-to when I’m feeling all emo.)
  • “41 years married: I Belong to You.”
  • “I’m having a hot flash. Both Sides Now will keep me cool.”
  • “You’re part of The Story,” from a fan whose sign listed the State Fair show the day before her diagnosis, Red Rocks on her cancer anniversary, and tonight: “Still here!”
  • One fan in a head-to-toe vulva costume, holding a sign that just said “100.”
Three fans seated in a row each hold a handmade sign reading Pride and Joy.
Three requests for “Pride & Joy” in one row.

Part of the magic was in getting to watch them work. Quick vocal warm-ups. Guitar tunings between songs. The three of them practicing the start and the stop of a song they hadn’t played in a minute, and singing quick phrases at each other to find the harmony. She joked that she can’t read music, she just remembers shapes (where her hands go for each chord), and then she drew on her guitar with the Sharpie so she wouldn’t lose her place. Every mom in the audience, having visions of rogue stolen-Sharpie marks on walls and furniture, gasped.

Brandi and the twins were as present as ever. They opened with “The Things I Regret.” She found a fan whose last chemo treatment was the next day and played “My Song” for her. She did Alphaville’s “Forever Young” by herself at the keys. She told somebody their sign was upside down. They tossed us guitar picks. She autographed signs from the stage.

Brandi Carlile, in a plaid blazer, bends to sign a fan's Dying Day sign with a marker on stage.
Carlile signs a fan’s “Dying Day” sign from the stage.

They played Radiohead’s “Creep” and Alanis Morissette’s “Uninvited.” We got the Indigo Girls’ “Ghost,” in the same room where I watched the Indigo Girls four weeks ago. We got “Nothing Compares 2 U,” in Prince’s town, with a guitar solo from Tim that I could watch on repeat.

Brandi Carlile sings into a microphone while seated at a keyboard under magenta light.
Carlile at the keys.

By the end of the night the pad had more than two dozen songs on it.

A large white pad on an easel lists 27 handwritten song titles, with Brandi Carlile seen from behind in the foreground.
The setlist, written in Sharpie as the night went.

And the harmonies. We’ve all watched her well-deserved meteoric ascent like proud parents as she’s sold out major venues worldwide these past few years. I loved her at Xcel. Loved her at resort amphitheaters in Mexico.

But in an arena they can’t walk away from their mics to the front of the stage, ask for pin-drop silence, and sing “This Time Tomorrow” a cappella. The room went still, and we got that quiet euphoria you feel when you hear how well those three voices fit together after all these years.

They moved to a little balcony for “Cannonball,” acoustic, the harmonies just as tight.

Phil and Tim Hanseroth lean in on either side of Brandi Carlile as the three sing into one microphone in a balcony.
The trio in the balcony, around one microphone.

This was the Brandi a lot of us have been missing. To tell you the truth, I wasn’t ready for it. She sang “Wherever Is Your Heart” and it occurred to me that, damn, I haven’t really processed this divorce, have I? (Noted. In pink.)

This concert was for us. Fitting that it came two days after she picked up four Grammy nominations for Returning to Myself, because her return to herself was also her coming back to us, a bit. She said the nominations meant a lot because they came from other artists and songwriters.

After “The Joke,” which lands differently in Minneapolis after the year we’ve had with ICE, it was “Christmas 1984” and “Hard Candy Christmas,” plus the news that she has 24 Christmas trees in her cabin. That sounded like a rural-lesbian-to-rural-lesbian challenge to me, and you know what? Accepted.

The big ones came at the end. “The Mother.” “The Story.” “Turpentine.” My faves didn’t make the setlist, but they’re all our faves, aren’t they?

She first headlined in the Twin Cities at the 400 Bar in February 2006. Twenty years later she talked about that club from the stage and told us she’ll always come home.

On Wednesday she did. I have it in my notes.

Set list: State Theatre, Nov. 18, 2026

Twenty-eight songs, in the order they played them.

  1. The Things I Regret
  2. My Song
  3. Forever Young (Alphaville cover)
  4. In the Morrow
  5. This Time Tomorrow
  6. Fulton County Jane Doe
  7. Creep (Radiohead cover)
  8. Same Old You (Miranda Lambert cover)
  9. Nothing Compares 2 U (Prince cover)
  10. Wherever Is Your Heart
  11. Angel From Montgomery (John Prine cover)
  12. Uninvited (Alanis Morissette cover)
  13. Most of All
  14. Letter to the Past
  15. Right on Time
  16. A War With Time
  17. Fall Apart Again
  18. The Joke
  19. The Heartache Can Wait
  20. Christmas 1984
  21. Hard Candy Christmas (Dolly Parton cover)
  22. You and Me on the Rock
  23. Dying Day
  24. Cannonball
  25. Ghost (Indigo Girls cover)
  26. The Mother
  27. The Story
  28. Turpentine

See the full set of photos from the night.

This was one of 45 Minnesota concerts on our list. See every time Brandi Carlile has played Minnesota.

Q Minnesota attended on press credentials provided by Hennepin Arts. Hennepin Arts did not review this piece before publication.

More from Q Minnesota

Keep reading · Arts & Entertainment