Theater has a way of bringing unexpected stories to life, and On Q goes behind the scenes with the artists making them happen. In this online-only Q&A series, we talk with the performers and creative minds shaping the Twin Cities theater scene, exploring the stories they tell and how they bring them to the stage.
“Equal parts hilarious, horny and heartbreaking.” So describes the queer theatrical cabaret “Double Indumbnity” that embraces the absurdity of life, love and everything in between. The show takes audiences on an unpredictable ride through sexuality, relationships, identity and the messier corners of the human experience. Drawing on the traditions of cabaret and comedy, the production finds humor in the uncomfortable and heart in the outrageous.
At the center of it all are Jonah Wheeler and John Coons, partners in life and creative collaborators whose individual talents make for an unconventional theatrical pairing. Wheeler merges a background in musical theater alongside his work as an adult performer and creator of educational content exploring queer sexuality and kink. Coons is a songwriter, playwright and vocalist whose experience spans everything from classical music to pop and musical theater. Together, they’ve created three full-length works, with “Double Indumbnity” continuing their tradition of blending sharp wit and musical talent with unapologetic queer expression.
Question: How did you land on this particular blend of cabaret, comedy and chaos, and what can audiences expect when they walk into “Double Indumbnity”?
Jonah Wheeler: We probably come to this a little bit from our own creative practices. For me, I’m coming out of my online persona. I’m a pornographer and a social media person. And so much of what I do is trying to be both ridiculous and insightful about the sex that I’m presenting. So trying to be nuanced, surprising, and present are the values that have really come to the front of what my work is, so I wanted to put that into this piece. Even when we’re, like, “be impressive about songs, and do things you know, and tell jokes,” I want to take the values that come with me from my porn practice over to here.
John Coons: And I’m a depressed person with lots of depressed friends, so we do lots of gallows humor. And then we both give it sass! [Laughs].

Question: How does your relationship influence the material you create and perform together? Do you have to establish some boundaries when the curtain comes down?
Coons: Boundaries?! [Laughs] I think we get a lot of inspiration from just being idiots on the daily together. And then we’ll see what the other one laughs at and then be like, “Ah, if I can get a good zinger in on them and they’ve got very high standards, then it’s probably good enough for a show.”
Wheeler: As for what the performing is like together, being on stage with them is its own kind of sex, really. It’s about being very present. It’s about reading the signals. It’s about going, “Oh, I see where you’re going in this moment. Let me go with you. Let me counter you.” And as for boundaries, the boundary we have is in the creative process in that we’re both musicians, they are the writer and I’m the arranger. And so I say, “Hey, when you come to me, you need to bring me a melody, a lyric, a sense of harmony and a style, and I can flesh things out from there.” And then once we’ve both done our processes, we can bounce that back and forth. But there are parts of the process where I have my boundaries of, I will not participate in lyric writing or conceptualizing. But when you do that, oh man, I’m going to dress it up good and nice.
Question: Both of you bring some wonderfully unexpected experiences to the stage. How do those seemingly different worlds find their way into the show, and what happens when you bring them together?
Coons: Well, cabaret I’ve always loved because it is such a melting pot and you can do a classical art song next to an original singer-songwriter song next to a jazz song next to a pop song. And if you want, you can even start mashing them up, too. So, I think, just the idea that it’s a great place for all sensibilities as long as it’s being filtered through a very singular point of view. And I think we’ve gotten very good at creating kind of a duo point of view that then we can just take any influence we want and just shove it through, like dough through a pasta maker.
Wheeler: We do have a lot of shared background of interests and values. I would call us both old souls. We have a lot of older reference points. One of my favorites is this ’60s audio comedy group, the Firesign Theatre, who did this lengthy comedic film noir parody called “The Further Adventures of Nick Danger” that’s very psychedelic and goofy. And we know very few people who’ve heard of this, but both of us grew up with it extensively and can quote it at great length. And in tribute to that, there is a horny and pun laden film noir parody early in the show. It’s part of why the show’s called “Double Indumbnity.” It’s a reference to the 1944 film noir, “Double Indemnity.” And yeah, we have these shared reference points despite our different performing traditions that really link us together across our different values.

Question: How important is it to create a space where queer audiences can see their experiences reflected without necessarily having to take themselves too seriously?
Wheeler: It’s exceptionally important! I mean, that’s kind of the point of the show. Of course this is for queer audiences. We love queer audiences. We also did make this with the point of being like, “hey, people who are not queer identifying, there are aspects of queerness that are useful to you. These things that are great for us are not just great for us. They are widely applicable if you are daring enough to accept them in yourself.”
Coons: Yeah, I think it’s a good part of every person’s diet. Everybody should be eating 20% more queer. And I also find that a lot of our audiences, continuing with that, are very hungry for it. So we’re very specific curators and caterers on tour.
Wheeler: And I did start with, yeah, this is applicable to straight people too, but I don’t know, queer people need some extra love a lot of the time and we are very happy to give it.
Question: This is your third full-length collaboration. How has your creative partnership evolved over those productions, and what are you still discovering about yourselves as performers and collaborators?
Coons: Our first show was called “Bleak: Songs for the Not Quite End of the World,” and it was essentially a solo show that you arranged and music directed.
Wheeler: Yeah, I assisted in that one.
Coons: I don’t think you said any lines in it.
Wheeler: I had a couple.
Coons: Yeah. But that was primarily that first full length project. And then ever since we’ve been pulling Jonah out from behind the piano more and more and more. And it’s been really, really wonderful to see him not just take a couple of singing numbers and to get more daring in that, but to really see the way that he’s evolved as a storyteller. And that really gets electric and kind of explodes in this one in a really nice way.
Wheeler: I’m loving the way that a live show allows me to be unfiltered in a way that on social media I have to meet the, “you can’t say these words, you can’t address these topics, you can’t speak positively about this topic or we will ban you.” And I can say what I like in front of an audience. As far as how has our collaborative process developed over time, I love how we’ve gotten very efficient, particularly in this show, in how much information we can say with how little amount of material. This show is very dense.

Coons: It’s very fast-paced. And now that we know what works with our particular audience that we’ve built, we’re off with the starter’s pistol. It’s a race the entire time.
Wheeler: There’s no fat in this one. It’s just here, here’s the material.
Coons: And then about halfway through, it speeds up.
Wheeler: There’s a thing we’ve done in this one, because we built this show to do it in Puerto Vallarta, where we didn’t know how queer the audience was going to be. We knew it would be a gay audience, but we didn’t know how expansive and willing to play they would be. So we start the show at a somewhat introductory level of like, here’s the tone we’re going to be at. And each number we build a little bit on how much we need you to listen and how much you need to let your barriers come down. And it’s funny, depending on what town we’re in, some places like Puerto Vallarta, people are starting really at the level of song one. And in New Orleans and San Francisco, they’re starting at the level of song four. We’ve built this to lift an audience in queerness along for the ride so everybody’s able to be on board for the experience by the time we hit the hard material six numbers in.
Coons: Yeah, full rocket take off!
This interview has been edited for length and clarity.
“Double Indumbnity” will be at Amsterdam Bar & Hall in St. Paul on Nov. 18. For more information and to purchase tickets, head to amsterdambarandhall.com.








